Business Baron

What happens when the EHO turns up

An environmental health inspection at a restaurant is unannounced. Here is what the officer looks at first, what notices they can serve and how to appeal.

, Hospitality

It is quarter past eleven on a Wednesday, you have a delivery half put away and a chef who has not arrived. A woman in a plain jacket shows you an identity card and says she is from environmental health. She does not have an appointment and does not need one. The next ninety minutes will determine your hygiene rating for the following two years.

They arrive unannounced, and their powers are statutory

Food safety enforcement in the United Kingdom is carried out by local authorities, with national oversight from the Food Standards Agency. The officer is usually an environmental health officer or a food safety officer authorised by the council.

Under the Food Safety Act 1990 and the food hygiene regulations that sit under it, an authorised officer has the right to enter food premises at any reasonable hour, and for a business trading in the evening, the evening is a reasonable hour. They can inspect the premises, examine records, take photographs, take samples, and inspect and seize food they consider unfit. Obstructing an officer is itself an offence. Asking them to come back another day is not a right you have.

How often you see them depends on your risk score, which is set at the previous inspection from the type of food you handle, the numbers of people at risk, the standards found and the confidence the officer had in your management. A high risk business may be visited annually or more. A well-run low risk one may go years. Complaints, a suspected outbreak or a change of ownership all bring a visit forward, as does registering a new business, which every food business must do with its local authority, normally at least 28 days before opening, free of charge.

What they look at, roughly in order

Officers work in a consistent pattern, and knowing it removes most of the panic.

Temperature control first, because it is objective and it is where illness comes from. Fridges and freezers, hot holding, cooling of cooked food, and the probe you use to check, along with its calibration. Chilled food is generally required to be held at 8°C or below, and most operations work to 5°C to give themselves margin, while hot holding is at or above 63°C.

Cross-contamination next. Separation of raw and ready to eat food in storage and preparation, colour coded boards used properly, cleaning of surfaces between tasks, hand washing facilities with soap and a hygienic means of drying, and whether the wash hand basin is accessible or has a stack of trays in it.

Then the structure: the condition of floors, walls and ceilings, pest evidence, ventilation, lighting, drainage and the state of equipment.

Then the paperwork, which is where operators lose most ground. The officer wants your food safety management system, based on hazard analysis principles, which for most small businesses means a completed Safer Food, Better Business pack or equivalent. They will look at whether the records are being completed daily rather than reconstructed, whether the system matches the menu you are actually serving, staff training records, allergen information and how it is communicated, supplier traceability, and your cleaning schedule.

Finally they will talk to you, and to whoever is working. Confidence in management is a formal component of the assessment, and it is built or lost in how you answer. An operator who knows their own system, can find a record without searching, and describes what they do when something goes wrong scores well. One who blames staff does not.

Advice, improvement notices and prohibition are three different things

Most inspections end with verbal advice and a written report listing what must be done, what should be done, and by when. That is the normal outcome and it is not a sanction.

Where there is a contravention of food hygiene regulations, an officer can serve a hygiene improvement notice. It must specify what is wrong, what you must do to put it right, and a period to comply, which cannot be less than 14 days. Failing to comply with the notice is an offence, prosecuted in the magistrates' court. You can appeal a hygiene improvement notice to a magistrates' court, generally within one month of the date of service or before the compliance date, whichever is earlier.

Where the officer believes there is an imminent risk of injury to health, the powers change entirely. A hygiene emergency prohibition notice can be served on the spot, closing the business or prohibiting the use of particular equipment or a process immediately. That is not a request and it takes effect at once. The authority must then apply to a magistrates' court within three days for a hygiene emergency prohibition order confirming it. If the court does not confirm, the authority must compensate you for the closure, which is a real protection and a genuine constraint on the power being used lightly.

There are also voluntary closures. An officer may suggest you close while you deal with a drainage failure or a pest infestation. Agreeing avoids the formal record of a prohibition, and it is still a closure. Take advice before agreeing to anything described as voluntary.

Separately, the courts can impose a prohibition order on a person, preventing them from managing a food business. That is the most serious outcome and it follows conviction.

What to do on the day, and in the two years before it

On the day: be polite, be present, and do not obstruct. Ask for identification and note the officer's name. Have someone accompany them throughout, taking your own notes and photographs of anything they photograph. Do not argue about findings in the moment, and do not have staff volunteer explanations. Fix anything immediately fixable while they are there, because it is recorded. Ask, before they leave, what the main issues are and what would improve the rating, and write down the answer.

Afterwards, request the written report if it has not been left with you, and deal with the items in writing with dates and receipts. If you disagree with a rating rather than a notice, the appeal is to the local authority and normally within 21 days.

Before it, though, is where the work actually is. The inspection assesses two years of habits in ninety minutes. Records completed daily, a system updated when the menu changed, temperature logs that are not all in the same handwriting and the same pen, a pest contract with the reports filed, and staff who have been trained and can say so. The businesses that fear the unannounced visit are the ones whose paperwork gets written the night before. The ones who barely notice are running the same system whether anybody is coming or not.

Where this shows up in the game

Restaurants and takeaways are part of Business Baron's full game, and cafés and pubs are free to run. Each regime visits on its own risk rating, pulled forward by complaints, and asks for the records you kept, and the ladder runs from advice to a notice that closes you that day. The grade that follows is public, and the trade follows the grade.

Read next