Business Baron

Lane metres, tides and the dry dock

A ferry operator business in the UK sells lane metres, not seats. How freight pays the winter, what the MCA can do, and why a detention ends seasons.

, Specialist industries

Six in the morning on a linkspan in February. Eleven lorries are queued for a sailing with room for forty, the stern door is open, and the crossing will run on time because the tide says it can.

There are no cars. There will be no cars until Easter, and the freight in that queue is the reason the route is still open. The hauliers book the same sailings every week of the year and they do not care what the weather is doing to the tourist trade.

A ferry sells space on a vehicle deck, measured in lane metres, and the sailing list is written round the tide table and the dry dock window rather than round demand. The port charges its dues whether the ship sails full or nearly empty.

Capacity is measured in metres of deck

The unit is the lane metre, not the seat. A lorry takes a long stretch of it and a car takes a short one, and the question at every sailing is how much of what you sailed you actually sold.

That is why the mix matters so much. Freight pays the winter and cars pay the summer, and a route with only one of them is a route in trouble. An August sailing full of cars and caravans looks wonderful and is over by September. A Tuesday night freight sailing looks like nothing and runs fifty-two weeks a year.

The fares are small, a few tens of pounds a crossing on a short route, and the volumes are large. Around half of what comes in survives the direct cost of carrying it, which sounds comfortable until you notice how much of that direct cost is fixed. Crew, fuel and port dues are very nearly the same with forty cars aboard as with four hundred.

Two dates changed the shape of this trade without changing the arithmetic. The Channel Tunnel opened in 1994 and took a share of the short sea traffic. Duty free on journeys within the European Union ended on 30 June 1999, which removed a revenue line that had been quietly paying for cheap fares.

The timetable is written by the tide and the dry dock

Most businesses choose their opening hours. A ferry operator negotiates them with the moon, the port's berth availability and a classification survey.

Every vessel comes out of service for weeks at a time, and it is never a convenient month. You either cancel the sailings, which hands your freight customers to the next port along, or you charter in a replacement that nobody likes and that costs more than the ship it is standing in for. Operators on supported lifeline routes plan a spring dry dock every year and still find it painful.

The counterweight is that a supported route is paid to sail whatever the loadings. A lifeline service let under a long contract is the most stable revenue in the transport family, and it is why a two-vessel operator on a supported route can plan years ahead while a competitor on an unsupported one cannot plan a season.

Entry is expensive and the range is wide, from roughly £4,000,000 to £35,000,000 depending on whether you are running an estuary foot ferry or a roll-on roll-off vessel on a short sea crossing. There are perhaps forty-five operators of any size in Britain and something like twelve thousand people working for them, which is a sense of the scale rather than a published figure. Crew are the biggest line after fuel, at around £38,000 for a qualified seafarer, and the ship needs its full complement whether the deck is loaded or not.

The Maritime and Coastguard Agency can hold the ship alongside

A passenger vessel carries a safety certificate covering its construction, its equipment, its stability and the number of people it may carry. The company holds a document of compliance under the international safety management arrangements, and the ship holds the certificate that goes with it. There is a crew accommodation and employment certificate under the maritime labour rules, and the vessel itself is registered on the UK Ship Register.

The Maritime and Coastguard Agency enforces all of this, and it also carries out port state control inspections. The power that matters is detention. A surveyor who finds a deficiency can hold the ship alongside until it is put right, and can suspend the certificate. Neither decision is appealable on a timescale that saves the sailings.

The bar and the galley are treated exactly as they would be ashore. The catering operation needs a food business registration with the local authority and the bar needs a premises licence, which is the point at which a ferry operator discovers it is also running a small pub company.

Almost nothing on the ticket carries VAT

Passenger transport in a vessel carrying ten or more passengers is zero rated, and international transport is zero rated in any case, under the VAT Act 1994, Schedule 8, Group 8.

For a ferry that means the fare, the car and the lorry all arrive without VAT. It is one of the few trades where the headline price and the money you keep are the same number, and it makes a real difference to how a fare increase feels to both sides.

The exception is the part of the ship that is not transport. On domestic sailings the shop and the restaurant are standard rated in the ordinary way, so a small slice of the revenue does carry VAT and does need accounting for separately. That slice is also where a surprising amount of the margin lives on a short crossing, which is why the shop is always between you and the stairs.

A detention in July is how it ends

The failure is quick and it is usually technical.

An inspection finds a deficiency. The ship is detained for a fortnight in the middle of the season. The sailings are cancelled, but the port dues, the crew wages and the finance carry on exactly as before. The passengers rebook with somebody else for this summer. The hauliers, who are the ones who matter, move their weekly bookings to the next port and stay there, because a haulier who has rerouted once has already done the hard part.

That is what makes a ferry unlike an ordinary small business. Its timetable is set by the moon, its capacity is measured in metres of deck rather than seats, and one vessel out of service takes the whole route with it. There is no second branch to carry the month.

Where this shows up in the game

Ferry Operator is one of the specialist trades in Business Baron, and like all of them it runs on top of the full game.

The decision you make is the sailing list for the season, written against the tide table, the dry dock window and the berth the port can actually give you. The number you watch is lane metres sold as a share of lane metres sailed, which matters far more than how many people are aboard. Winter is freight or it is nothing, and the summer has to carry the year.

The Maritime and Coastguard Agency turns up as an inspection you did not schedule, and the power it has is to stop the ship where it stands. That is how the business ends: a detention in the wrong fortnight, a cancelled week, costs that do not pause, and a freight customer who has found another route by the time you are sailing again. The Ferry Operator page sets out the setup range, the margins and the certificates the trade runs on.

Read next